I really think this is a very good question. The unsatisfactory situation right now is that on 10-inch tablets, by default you get gigantic space traffic with a single column “mobile” site when the desktop version would be great.
Unfortunately, as John Hunt found out, even WURFL does not give an exact physical screen size.
One half-circle is the heuristic, which assumes that if the size of x or y is less than 768 pixels, then you are on the phone (*) and thus use the default "mobile" version of your site by default.
You should always allow the visitor to choose between a mobile or a desktop. Better yet, just call it the “single column” or “thin width” version of your site to avoid misuse.
(*) Why 768 pixels? Because all 10 "tablets of any importance have at least 1024x768 or 1280x800, while even phones with large screens such as the iPhone 5 or HTC HD5 have a width of less than 768 pixels (iPhone 5-640x1136, HTC HD5 1280x720). This, probably won't work on gigantic samsung screens, but on these devices, when the desktop version running by default is not so annoying.
source share