(+6 months) experience with Magnolia and Jahia, which is better?

Question

we learn CMS based on java (yes java, we move away from scripting languages).

Does anyone have experience working with community editions of Magnolia and Jahia to make module building easier and your overall experience?

• For content editors
• For developers (who make modules)
• How easy it is to process a change request (can you add one or the other to the foo / bar page)

RVT

Answer 1

Disclaimer: I am Jahia CTO. I hope this answer is acceptable by StackOverflow standards, otherwise, please let me now and I will improve it. At first I wanted to answer as a direct comment on the answer, but this is not possible.

, GKrost, ( , Jahia), .

Jahia :

JCR (10000+ , > 50000 ), mysql. Java-In-memory-DB .

JCR , . JCR, Jackrabbit. , , HSQLDB (http://hsqldb.org), ​​ , , . , , - JVM, CMS, .

, 10000+ , , . 10000+ , Jahia 6.5 CMS, . 50000, . , , , , , CMS, , ElasticSearch, .

Jahias Lucene

Jahia default Lucene - , Jabrabbit JCR. Jahia 7, OSGi, Lucene ElasticSearch , , JCR-. , CMS OSGi, Magnolia ( Adobe, Apache Sling, OSGI -).

/ JSP, JSF ( Jahia Spring Webflow, , ...)

JSP/ Groovy/Velocity , API- Java Scripting. Spring Webflow Jahia 7, , Spring WebFlow (http://www.jahiaone.com/home/program/session/MVC-in-Jahia7-Using-SpringWebFlow). JSP, , - , Java-. JSF , , JSF .

- , .

. SLA , : http://www.jahia.com/services/technical-assistance. .

/

2 , .

/ ;

. / , , . , , , . JCR, . .

Jahia , . , , node, , .

, . Jahia 6.5 , . , , . () , node , , .

. db. Jahia () MySQL Cluster. (: BLOB/CLOB, MySQL)

, . , MySQL, BLOB/TEXT, . Oracle, . Jahia , PostgreSQL Microsoft SQL Server, .

, JavaDoc/Source

, , . JavaDocs : http://downloads.jahia.com/downloads/jahia/digitalfactory7.0.0/digital-factory-root-7.0.0.0-javadoc/, - , .

; jahia jahia.

, , , , , , . Jahia , , , , , ? , , , JahiaOne . , , .

( , jahia)

. , , .

Answer 2

. Jahia, Magnolia, Magnolia. , , . Magnolia jsp. Jahia , java-, , , .

, Magnolia, (Magnolia .) : www.franchiseprocess.com. , , , .

Answer 3

Jahia :

• //, CMS Java
• Jahia .
• - JCR, .

Jahia :

• JCR (10000+ , > 50000 ) , mysql. Java-In-Memory-DB .
• Jahias Lucene .
• / JSP, JSF ( Jahia Spring Webflow, , ...)
• - , .
• / .
• / ;
• Jahia , . , , node, , .
• . db. Jahia () MySQL Cluster. (: BLOB/CLOB, MySQL)
• , JavaDoc/Source
• ; jahia jahia.
• ( , jahia)

Answer 4

Jahia , Apache Roller:

http://web.archiveorange.com/archive/v/PxZtPQyYMTldSEuEePMb

Answer 5

. , , . , , jQuery Jahia.

Magnolia , (, pgAdmin) "" Magnolia, , , , , . , .

Jahia: . 4000 . . jahia , mucg , , , 1-2 (3 ), - Jahia, skype, , .

Answer 6

.

• : -, tempalte, , ,
• , , Jahia .
• . - .
• .

: - - -, -

Answer 7

JCR , . JCR . , 1000 ( ). 4 JCR.

, JCR. - . - , "-" CMS. , , . , "lookup content", , -, - ( " " ).

Jahia is certainly a very interesting solution, but the need to rely on the DBMS (and, therefore, on unnecessary integration dependency) is a big "console" for enterprise solutions. Scaling is also not easy, while with Magnolia I can configure a new instance of “publish” (or “render”) at any time, increasing performance and security (fault tolerance).