Or if you want to use data.table:
library(data.table)
dt[,sum(!is.na(X2)),by=.(Color)]
Color V1
1: Red 2
2: Blue 0
3: Green 1
ifelse() data.table, NA , 0. :
dt[,ifelse(sum(!is.na(X2)==0),as.integer(NA),sum(!is.na(X2))),by=.(Color)]
Color V1
1: Red 2
2: Blue NA
3: Green 1
:
dt <- as.data.table(fread("Color X1 X2 X3 X4
Red 1 1 0 2
Blue 0 NA 4 1
Red 3 4 3 1
Green 2 2 1 0"))