Nodejs crypto.pbkdf2 result is different from CryptoJS.PBKDF2

Question

I work with PBKDF2 on the interface (CryptoJS) and the backend (Node.js), both derived keys should be equal, so I use the same salt, the same algorithm, the same number of iterations, the same password, but the derived key is different.

This is the browser code / cryptoJS, in the comment the sample salt and key. (Hexadecimal)

<script type="text/javascript" src="pbkdf2.js"></script>
<script type="text/javascript" src="sha512.js"></script>
<script>
var salt = CryptoJS.lib.WordArray.random(128 / 8);
var key512Bits = CryptoJS.PBKDF2('anacleto', salt, { hasher:CryptoJS.algo.SHA512, keySize: 512 / 32, iterations: 1 });
console.log(salt.toString(CryptoJS.enc.Hex));
// 1427f23fd32f8f9902768e7ab7c7ffad
console.log(key512Bits.toString(CryptoJS.enc.Hex));
// de3259de39fcc55531b91b4ffb2a6c29005c674cc95b3ec5bdf18412b6087d05921f3a0e4148fc34c88a04e980481d397a4c2b143edc0cb1bb5d7434ca3b4c25
</script>

And this is nodeJS code

var crypto = require('crypto');
var salt_hex = '1427f23fd32f8f9902768e7ab7c7ffad';
var key_hex = 'de3259de39fcc55531b91b4ffb2a6c29005c674cc95b3ec5bdf18412b6087d05921f3a0e4148fc34c88a04e980481d397a4c2b143edc0cb1bb5d7434ca3b4c25';
var salt = new Buffer(salt_hex, 'hex');
crypto.pbkdf2('anacleto', salt.toString('utf8'), 1, 512/8, 'sha512', function (err, key) {
  if (err)
    throw err;
  var x = key.toString('hex');
  var y = key_hex;
  console.assert(x === y, '\n' + x + '\n !== \n' + y);
});

And the console raises this assertion error:

AssertionError: 
efcca398dc0eb07aec6dcf2239dae83b79c2f82212b2cc0a21270fe251c73c7ab69f0133e75bf3ca6159242826ff3f26c64075f72cf86c67ba1199af29f6d576 
!== 
de3259de39fcc55531b91b4ffb2a6c29005c674cc95b3ec5bdf18412b6087d05921f3a0e4148fc34c88a04e980481d397a4c2b143edc0cb1bb5d7434ca3b4c25

As you can see, the key from node.js starts with "efcca" and CryptoJS starts with "de325".

Where is the mistake? Maybe this is another library implementation? Shouldn't be the same derived key?

Answer 1

var salt = CryptoJS.lib.WordArray.random(128 / 8);

, . UTF-8 node.js, , node.js.

crypto.pbkdf2('anacleto', salt.toString('utf8'), 1, 512/8,

to

crypto.pbkdf2('anacleto', salt, 1, 512/8,

crypto.pbkdf2('anacleto', salt.toString('binary'), 1, 512/8,